Criticism archive (Articles since 2006. For the 2000-2005 archive, click here)

Dreamers by Day published 20/03/2012

dreamsThe American dream, and just what it meant is one of the great themes of 20th century American literature. The tragedy that the American dream is an illusion meant to distract everyone from the bleak reality of their lives is another common theme. Nelson Algren was one of the writers who explored the latter theme best. Algren was championed by Studs, and is the dedicatee of American Dreams: Lost and Found. He moved away from Chicago to New Jersey in 1975, and passed away in 1981 - the year after Lost and Found came out.

Robert O’Connor continues his series on Studs Terkel with his look at the American dream in American Dreams, Lost and Found.

» Read it all...

Literature is what we are lost in published 18/03/2012

vladthumb-150x150.jpgVladislavić recalls how his eyes once alighted on a photograph, now well-known, of Robert Walser lying dead in the snow. Here the death of the author brings about the birth of writing, with Walser’s fallen, frozen figure stirring Vladislavić to ‘write a story about the last days, hours, minutes of a writer.’ But the story dies on its feet, first dispersing into digressions, then disappearing completely, just as Walser’s footprints ‘break off in mid-sentence,’ and his collapse ‘carries him onto the silence of a blank page.’ Writing is like dying and being born both at once.

David Winters on Ivan Vladislavić’s The Loss Library.

» Read it all...

He’s a great listener published 15/03/2012

talking

Studs talks about his time as an actor, from being a radio gangster to his television show “Studs’ Place,” which, along with “Garroway at Large” and “Kukla, Fran, and Ollie,” was the apex of Chicago-style television. NBC dropped the program and blacklisted Studs when he was suspected of being a communist. Afterwards, a florist named Ed Clamage, a member of the American Legion, would call Studs’ employers and warn them of his supposedly subversive leanings. One famous story from this is that Studs was paid $100 to give a talk. Clamage warned the venue and they doubled his speaking fee. Studs learned of this later and sent Clamage a note saying he owned him an agent’s fee and a check for $10. Clamage never endorsed it.

Robert O’Connor continues his look at Studs Terkel, with a book where he turns his interviewing methods on himself in Talking to Myself

» Read it all...

The Ironic High Style published 12/03/2012

justborisPost-expenses, Boris Johnson is the only contemporary politician to command near-universal public respect, his sex life could rival a Flashman or Don Draper, and he walks away laughing from controversies that would kill most public figures stone dead. Purnell’s biography can be read as a classic period entertainment, half the time you are just laughing at Boris’ antics and wondering what the loveable rogue will get up to next week. As Laurie Penny put it on the Daily Politics: ‘Sorry, it’s Boris, I still can’t believe he’s the Mayor of London, he’s a cartoon character… Every time I see his face on TV I go oh… oh, you’re Mayor…’ No one took him seriously until it was too late.

Max Dunbar reviews Sonia Purnell’s Just Boris.

» Read it all...

Not reviewing John Berger published 09/03/2012

bergerA pervasive trend in contemporary literature, most visible in the middlebrow but certainly not constrained within that region, doesn’t believe this, believing instead that empathy is an act of pure imaginative will. Take works with titles which follow the formula ‘The [slightly arty profession] of [name of war-torn city]’: perhaps The Bookseller of Kabul or The Cellist of Sarajevo, and I’m sure there are others. While the motive behind them is no doubt noble, they want to read modern history as a tale of localised goodies and baddies, in which the ‘human spirit’ ultimately wins out over, say, ‘greed’ or ‘corruption’ or ‘cruelty’. A Seventh Man, by contrast, is as convincing an argument for a Marxist humanism as ever there was: it sticks determinedly to its thesis that ‘understanding’ demands that imaginative resolve is accompanied by an understanding of objective processes.

Joe Kennedy on John Berger.

» Read it all...

Journey’s End published

perilouspassagePerilous Passage is no biography, and certainly no map through the invisible landscape, but Wilson’s own vision of events surrounding this extraordinary apprenticeship and initiation into The Third Mind – a psychic phenomenon of conjoined minds noted by Burroughs and Gysin during their experiments in the Beat Hotel in the 50s and 60s. In his words: “I am not so much trying to detail a teaching method… but rather to describe the effects of what he called the Process on those concerned, most particularly myself.” Transmuted into a tale of espionage, masks disguise the central players, dialogue obscures as much as it reveals and locations blur together outside of time.

Jon Crabb reviews Terry Wilson’s Perilous Passage.

» Read it all...

Kings Didn’t Build the Pyramids published 08/03/2012

working
In that introduction, Studs tells for the first time a story he would often tell later - of a woman who heard her voice for the first time on his tape recorder, and she exclaimed “I never knew I felt that way before.” The revelation to him was that he could capture the voice of what he called the “un-celebrated people,” the people who don’t appear in the newspaper headlines, photographs or in any kind of preserved media. What the woman learned, Studs would later tell, was that “she had a voice, and that it counts.” The thought going into Working was that these people who are uncelebrated and never heard from have dreams, thoughts and grievances that are bottled up, and with a tape recorder present, they would pour them out.

Robert O’Connor continues his series on Studs Terkel with his most famous work, Working.

» Read it all...

Keep the Motor Running published 07/03/2012

drivenIf James Sallis’ totemic Driver seemed somehow superhuman in the original Drive, then in its sequel, things have evolved even further. In Driven, the now-Nietzschean wheelman becomes all too real, all too human, yet achieves greater impact this time through his perceived weakness and vulnerability, rather than raw strength and power. That isn’t to say there isn’t as much violence or throat-kicking to be had. Sallis maintains his style of filmic time signatures and underplayed delivery and, by working in a love interest, several new faces, and even a new identity, builds exhilaratingly on the mythology of his soon-to-be-timeless Zarathustra.

Declan Tan on James SallisDriven.

» Read it all...

The Nietzschean Brain published 06/03/2012

41klp-aldlThere’s a need for left-wing politics, for understanding ourselves as human animals on a planet where the incredible mammalian brain has the potential to solve how we can live together in peace and harmony with our world. Churchland and her naturalist posse keep slamming down the facts and the theories. We need to keep lapping it up, learning it, arguing with it, finding out more and more and get it put to good use to protect or hospitals, our schools, our communities, we need to abolish poverty and war. We need to get with the programme.

Richard Marshall reviews Patricia Churchland’s Braintrust: What Neuroscience Tells Us About Morality.

» Read it all...

The Tangible Past published 03/03/2012

hardtimes
The hotels were always booked, and had a waiting list all through the 1920s. But then, the Great Depression hit and their customers went away. Studs would always say that the symbol of the Depression to him was the neon “vacancy” sign put in the Wells-Grand at the start of the Depression.

Robert O’Connor continues his look at Studs Terkel with his most ambitious book yet, Hard Times.

» Read it all...