:: Criticism archive ( click for articles pre-2006)

GDP published 16/03/2014

‘Acceptance of the new measure for this period [pre 1950] would involve a major reinterpretation of American history.’ US productivity would be shown to be lower than the UK in 1914, and growth of GDP was lower than the UK by 1929. In the 1970s Thatcher came to power on the back of a calculation of the GDP that showed the UK economy in crisis. But later recalculation showed that things weren’t as bad as had been originally thought.

Richard Marshall on Diane Coyle’s GDP.

»

Borges’s funes the memorious published 09/03/2014

In 1887 John Langdon Down lectured on what he called ‘idiot savants’ . The film ‘Rain Man’ features a character with this syndrome. The film is based on Kim Peek who is said to have the most astonishing memory on earth. It was estimated that he knew the content of 12,000 books. He could read different pages of a book with different eyes. He read eight pages in 53 seconds and recalled 98% of what he’d read. He couldn’t filter. He had limited capacity to reason. Any problem not based on memory stumped him or proved difficult. He only read factual books. Multiple interpretation and ambiguity was avoided. He processed information literally. He ended talks around the world saying, ‘We are all different. You don’t have to be handicapped to be different. Treat other people like you would like to be treated and the world will be a better place.’

Richard Marshall reads Quiroga on Borges and Memory.

»

why fight poverty etc published 23/02/2014

We need a much better understanding of how we support each other, and how money – and other support – is passed around and within families before we can think about reducing poverty. We need to understand the very different experiences of poverty, and how gender, disability and ill health all influence someone’s chances of becoming poor. We need to know more about the role of culture, attitude and behaviour in shaping people’s experience of poverty.

Richard Marshall reviews the new Perspectives series.

»

The Only Murderer Is the Reader published 18/02/2014

Should a science-fiction story be discounted for presenting us with implausible scenarios? The contradiction inherent in the generic label—verifiable “science” against untrammeled “fiction”—implies that authors should be granted carte blanche to imagine anything they wish so long, of course, as they can convince their readers of their constructs’ solidity. When a novel presents us with a world visibly different from our own, but fails to convince us that this fictional reality still adheres to a coherent set of rules, the spell is broken. The muddy foundation becomes disappointingly visible through the timber frame.

Jeffrey Zuckerman reviews Marek Huberath‘s Nest of Worlds

»

The Post-Feminism Mystique published 11/02/2014

Eat My Heart Out has been compared to Bret Easton Ellis, Kathy Acker, Lena Dunham’s Girls and early Amis, but transcends all these influences. Contra Fay Weldon, literary fiction has little time for people born post 1980, let alone people born post 1990. There is a world of struggling emergent youth out there that is simply unrepresented. Despite their first-class education Ann-Marie and her contemporaries are fighting for service jobs and floor space in a rigged game. Pilger started young — she is 29 and began writing this novel in late 2010 — and so is able to capture parts of London life that don’t even register on the establishment literary radar.

Max Dunbar reviews Zoe Pilger‘s Eat My Heart Out.

»

The Utter Silence of the Andalusian Refugee published 09/02/2014

The feeling that everything was broken and ruined, that desolation and exile were the true realities, was rooted in his own experiences in Andalusia, and his subsequent life as an exile and refugee. He referred to himself as ‘The Spaniard’ or ‘The Andalusian.’ He wrote to a Yemenite sage: ‘ I am one of the humblest scholars of Spain whose prestige is low in exile. I am always dedicated to my duties, but have not attained the learning of my forbearers, for evil days and hard times have overtaken us and we have not lived in tranquility; we have laboured without finding rest. How can the Law become lucid to a fugitive from city to city, from country to country? Have everywhere pursued the reapers and gathered ears of grain, both the solid and the full, as well as the shriveled and thin. Only recently have I found a home.’

Richard Marshall reviews Moshe Halbertal’s Maimonides.

»

The Private Life published 04/02/2014


The private life isn’t simply what we do when we’re at home, but owes more to the fact of not being at home … This is the wisdom of Freud, and of Blanchot. For the latter, the myth of Orpheus and Eurydice is about the passion for the invisible; Orpheus’s impossible desire to see Eurydice not when she is visible and worldly, but when she is invisible and obscure. This, for Cohen, is the private life. It’s that which can’t be brought to light because that’s precisely where it hides; that which can’t be paraded on TV or kept discretely behind closed curtains. ‘This isn’t a secret lurking in the dark. It’s right there on the face across the breakfast table, in the mirror.’ Arendt’s logic finds an unexpected corollary in tabloid snooping; both imagine that the private life can be reduced to secrecy; they simply differ on what is to be done with it. Both rub balm on a more unsettling fact: the less we hide, the more we’re hidden; even from ourselves. Aren’t your closest friends, your family, your lover, so much stranger to you than the person you pass on the street? Like that difficult book you held so close to your face that its long words blurred and became incomprehensible, the closer we draw people towards us, the more they confound us. The less you conceal the stranger you become.

Will Rees reviews Josh Cohen‘s The Private Life: Why We Remain in the Dark.

»

Time, History and Literature published 10/01/2014

Auerbach located in Dante a profound cultural change. Where ‘… the indestructibility of the whole historical and individual man turns against the divine order… and obscures it. The image of man eclipses the image of God. Dante’s work realized the Christian-figural essence of man, and destroyed it in the very process of realizing it.’ Here is another version of ‘reversal and continuation’, an extreme form that knows that the paradoxical realities embedded in religion are secular truths – and vice versa. To speak them threatens to erase everything, or walk you back to the start again for another attempt.

Richard Marshall reviews Auerbach’s Time, History, and Literature.

»

Stewart Home’s po-mo homer published 29/12/2013

Stewart Home’s ecstatic absurdity is an assault on modern culture bringing a Homeric pre-Socratic anti-Platonism to the table on the twin-back fun-ride of the funky German materialism started in the 1850s and the materialist-based Marxism a little later.

Richard Marshall on Stewart Home’s Proletarian Post-Modernism.

»

The map is not the territory published 26/12/2013

Critics of UE highlight the staunchly white, male and middle class demographic of what Garrett refers throughout as the ‘scene’. While Garrett’s own role as recent PhD researcher documenting it fits squarely in this bracket, the scene itself and the internet activity associated with it is without question bound entirely by one-upmanship and the fetishisation of photographic equipment (which join seamlessly in the ‘hero shot’ now associated with media reports of the groups’ activities e.g. masked solitary poses in sewer outfalls or on the ledge of tall buildings) and climbing kit, the book does little to dispel this.

Andrew Stevens reviews Bradley L. Garrett‘s Explore Everything: Place-hacking the City.

»