
By Sian Norris.
In her feminist treatise A Room of One’s Own, Virginia Woolf finds that in Restoration celebrity, writer, and aristocrat Margaret Cavendish, the Duchess of Newcastle, there “burnt the passion for poetry”, while her anger prevented her from writing with clear-sightedness (a case she also levels at Charlotte Brontë in the same text). Woolf writes:
what could bind, tame or civilize for human use that wild, generous, untutored intelligence? It poured itself out, higgledy-piggledy, in torrents of rhyme and prose, poetry and philosophy which stand congealed in quartos and folios that nobody ever reads.
In Margaret the First, a remarkable novel that re-tells Margaret Cavendish’s life, Danielle Dutton has pulled off the extraordinary feat of bringing to life that wildness, that generosity, and that passion for knowledge and understanding that so impressed Woolf, as well as redressing the silencing with which Margaret’s life and achievements have been met, and which Woolf mourns.
Just who was Margaret Cavendish? Margaret, the Duchess of Newcastle, married William Cavendish when she was twenty-two years old. A writer himself, William encouraged his wife’s education. She wrote plays, poems, and was a pioneer in the genre of science fiction with her 1666 work The Blazing World. As well as fiction, she composed tracts and published pamphlets about philosophy and the natural sciences, and was one of the first women to attend a Royal Society meeting.
Cavendish’s literary legacy goes beyond Woolf’s essay. As a proto-science fiction writer, her influence can be felt across the history of women’s literature. In 2014, Siri Husvedt titled her novel The Blazing World in tribute to Cavendish’s most famous work. The book, which explores the treatment and reception of women’s creativity in the art world, directly engages with Cavendish’s aesthetics and psychology, as well as the issues of credibility and reception that Cavendish faced. And it’s not just women writers that owe a debt to “Mad Madge”. Alan Moore’s The League of Extraordinary Gentleman has plenty of references to Cavendish’s fantastical imagination, as does China Mieville’s Un Lun Dun.
We can now add to that literary legacy Dutton’s Margaret the First.
Dutton’s book is split into three parts. The first, written in the first person, recounts Margaret’s life from childhood to marriage, and the Cavendishes’ exile from England to France and Antwerp. In the second part, the narrative voice switches to the third person, and deals with their return to England after the restoration of the monarchy. The final part, still in the third person, covers the period from the publication of The Blazing World to her death.
These shifts in narrative voice are important. In the first section of the novel, we are privy to Margaret’s inner thoughts as she grows into a young woman. We see the world through her eyes, and we see Margaret as she sees herself:
Kisses on the lawn at St John’s Green, a perfect summer gloom of vegetable bravado: peonies, bugloss, native beetles singing. The horses stamped a path through the starry dark. Alone in the carriage, flying through England, I imagined myself a beauty in satin; I imagined a crown of diamonds on my head…
It is through her inner voice that we first discover Margaret’s imaginative powers and her longing for adventure. The child Margaret plays in the stream of her childhood home, creating an entire world out of the shapes in the water and the foam on the river’s surface. In her childish fantasies, we see the beginnings of The Blazing World take shape, as she imagines an entire civilization of which she is queen:
I, Margaret, Queen of the Tree-People—discovered an invisible world. There, on the surface of the water, rive foam bubbles encased a jubilant cosmos. Whole civilizations lasted for only a moment! Yet from the creation of one of these Bubble-worlds to the moment that world popped into oblivion, the Bubble people within it fell in love, bore children, and died.
One particularly poignant moment is Dutton’s description of Margaret’s first period. As she makes this transition from girl to woman, Margaret actively mourns her childhood and the freedom it afforded her—a freedom she now realizes is only available to boys and men: “It is nobler to be a boy, I thought—and looked back with nostalgia, as if I just had been.”
Throughout the first section of the novel, the violence of the English Civil War intrudes on the narrative as news from home reports on the burning of homes and the defiling of corpses, Charles’s execution and the murders of Margaret’s relatives. Dutton neatly shows how the violence of war is both distant and close to Margaret. She offers a description of the peaceful and artificial beauty of aristocratic France:
Her summer chateau boasted grand suites with painted windows and formal gardens descending to the Seine, with canals and cascading fountains and a cove of faux-grottoes home to clacking metal birds, a bejewelled caterpillar, a golden duck that shook its head and quacked.
And then counters it with the brutality of war that has destroyed Margaret’s childhood home:
Fighting ensued at St. John’s Green. The house was destroyed, flattened. Our family vaults were again invaded, but this time it was my sister’s and mother’s coffins the mob defiled.
With these intrusions of death and destruction, Dutton brings to life the violence and confusion of the period—the juxtapositions between Margaret’s sheltered existence with the horror and violence that she can’t escape.
Dutton accomplishes quite a feat in fictionalizing Margaret’s entire life into a slim volume numbering 166 pages. We follow Margaret to Paris and Antwerp, we witness her marriage with William, and then we journey back with her to the Restoration Court in London, as the couple retreat to their country estate; we are with Margaret right through to her death.
Writing a novel rather than straight biography gives Dutton the freedom to focus on the big, blazing moments of Margaret’s life, the interior world she inhabits as well as the external world in which she lived and produced her work, all interspersed with the domestic details that are the bread of life. Interspersing fiction with the banality of domestic details, and poeticizing them, is not new to Dutton; indeed, this is terrain she covered throughout her entire paragraph-long novel SPRAWL to such powerful effect. Dutton is not only known for her experimental and daring prose because of SPRAWL, but also because of the work she publishes through her publishing house, The Dorothy Project, a press that focuses almost solely on female authors pushing boundaries and trying to make the marginal matter. As we would expect, then, Margaret the First is not—nor does it ever set out to be—a straight re-telling of Margaret’s life. Dutton takes a non-linear approach so that each big glowing moment of the novel shines on its own, and is allowed enough space and time so that the reader to relish the experience of reading Dutton’s pithy, poetic prose.
The switch to third person in the second and third sections of the novel coincides with the couple’s arrival in London. This change in narrative voice represents a shift from Margaret being a shy, retiring woman living out of the public eye to being the celebrity “Mad Madge” whose dress, antics, conversations, actions, and written work were the subject of gossip and jeers. Whereas before we experience Margaret as she sees herself, in the latter part of the book we view Margaret from the outside: Dutton thus causes the reader to shares the viewpoint of those who look at and talk about Margaret. She moves from being the subject to the object of the external gaze:
She climbs the wooden staircase, takes her place in the box. And like ripples in a summer pond, lines of faces slowly turn—from the gallery, the pit—she watches the ripple spread. William must be late, for beside her is an empty seat. Still more and more faces turn.
As in SPRAWL, Dutton pays minute and often uncanny attention to objects and the body. Dutton doesn’t shy away from Margaret’s body’s physicality—from a description of her starting her period, to Cavendish pinching her virginal nipples, and the horrifying concoctions pushed onto Margaret by doctors as she tries (unsuccessfully) to get pregnant. The level of detail is both fascinating and grotesque (and makes one grateful for modern medicine): “Come autumn I was to be injected in my rectum with a decoction of flowers one morning, followed by a day-long purge, using rhubarb and pepper.”
Fevers, deaths, constipation, leeches and blood—Dutton bombards the reader with intimate and uncomfortable physical detail. Like SPRAWL, this repetition of lists is effective in creating the sense that Margaret’s body is invaded by doctors and quacks who view her as a problem, an object to be cured.
The final section of Dutton’s novel is entitled, like Margaret’s great work, The Blazing World. It is this section that is most overtly feminist, dealing with the reception of Margaret’s writing and philosophy by both the intellectual and the society circles that swirl around the Restoration Court. We witness her anxiety that no one is reading her work, or that her work is subject to mockery, as well as her swelling of joy when her work is met with praise. In her anxiety and pride, we see a woman writer who wants to be taken seriously, who wants her work to be seen as important and interesting on its own terms, and who is desperate for validation. Yet she is writing in a world that views a woman with a pen as monstrous, a world that is more interested in her appearance and her personality than as an intellectual force.
It’s a battle that has been familiar to women writers throughout history. Are people more interested in Aphra Behn’s scandalous life than her poetry, for example? Do people prefer to debate whether Branwell Brontë wrote Wuthering Heights or whether Percy Bysshe Shelley wrote Frankenstein than to read either book and appreciate for them for their own merits? In the twentieth century, Gertrude Stein was well aware that her audience was often more interested in Stein the personality than Stein the writer. Today, the novelist Elena Ferrante actively hides her identity to escape the attention paid to her as a woman rather than her as a writer. It is a fight Margaret herself faced, and which Dutton chronicles in this fine novel. When Margaret goes to the Royal Society to talk with the men about her writing, she recognizes that they have come to look at her, to see the famous Mad Madge, rather than because they want to hear her views on science and philosophy: “That hat is too much, Pepys thinks—still, her shape is fine.”
Samuel Pepys’s observation of Margaret’s exterior shows us his lack of interest in her interiority. Throughout the novel, his thoughts (and the thoughts of others) are offered—each focused on the gossip and noise that surrounds Margaret, the “Mad Madge” of their social and intellectual spheres, rather than the woman herself. But despite all the noise that surrounds Margaret, her own intellect, creativity and passion for learning shines through—she cannot be silenced or repressed by the gossiping women and egotistical men around her. Dutton demonstrates Margaret’s belief in her own importance and genius through this reflection on The Blazing World:
[O]ne quiet day, having run out of questions, the empress is ready to share her ideas. She asks the spirits to send her a friend, one chosen from among the greatest modern writers; “Galileo,” she says, “Descartes?” But the spirits assure her that these men would scorn to be scribes to a woman, and they instead suggest an author called Margaret Cavendish, who writes, they tell the empress, nothing but sense and reason.
In Margaret the First, Dutton has written a remarkable book that gives us a joyous and minutely detailed insight into a female writer’s inner life. She brings to life in full colour, scent, and sound the history of one of our most remarkable and, sadly, as Woolf lamented, forgotten women. A decidedly feminist novel, the thrill for the reader lies in Margaret’s lively inner voice, along with Dutton’s imaginative prose. Her writing is inventive and artful, conjuring a luminous and colourful world just as extraordinary and innovative as Margaret’s own blazing world.
With Dutton’s novel, Margaret Cavendish will no longer be Woolf’s “crazy Duchess…a bogey to frighten clever girls with.” Instead, we discover an ambitious, hungry, and sensational woman who blazed and created and refused to be cowed by a society that saw her as an object of mere fun and gossip.

ABOUT THE AUTHOR
Sian Norris is a writer and feminist activist. She is the founder and director of the Bristol Women’s Literature Festival, and runs the successful feminist blog sianandcrookedrib.