3am magazine logo

The State of Us: An Interview with Charlie Hill

Charlie Hill interviewed by Katy Wimhurst.

 

3:AM: You’ve been writing for many years and The State of Us, a short story collection, is your fifth (sixth?) book. You have previously published novels and a memoir. What is it about writing that appeals so much and when did you start telling stories?

Charlie Hill: I don’t know when I started writing, but I do remember a story I read out at junior school. It was about a tiger hunt, and used lots of exclamation marks. The story went down well with my classmates — even now I feel the exclamation mark is an underrated piece of punctuation — and I’ve written ever since. Not always fiction though; for about ten years, I thought that nothing was as fun or illuminating or confounding as real life, so I stopped bothering with ‘stories’ (the relationship between the two had yet to fully reveal itself…). I’m not sure that writing has ever actually appealed, though. I think it’s closer to a compulsion than a choice or vocation.

3:AM: The blurb of The State of Us mentions Samuel Becket and elsewhere you have talked of your respect for Alain Robbe-Grillet and Anna Kavan. Can you say something about the literary influences on your writing? 

CH: There are writers I love — Robert Walser, Ilse Aichinger, Gwendolyne Brooks, for example — but I’m not sure any of them has been a particular influence on me. It’s true that I spent four or five years trying to write the sort of odd, textually slow-moving but intellectually mercurial fiction that Anna Kavan perfected but that was before I’d read any of her stuff, so I’m not sure that counts. I was influenced by Robbe-Grillet though, at least for a few years. Not that it was an altogether good fit. I admired what he was trying to do, but I’m not really someone who has fidelity to any particular theory. And I found the emphasis on repetition, and forming slightly austere patterns, took away the pleasure I take — and hope to communicate — in language and the construction of sentences. 

3:AM:  The State of Us is billed as satirical fiction. Ben Nicholson once said, ‘Satire is … deadly serious, and when politics begin to break down, there is a drift towards satire, because it’s the only thing that makes any sense.’ Certainly, a sense of anger about the state of our world comes through the book. Is satirical fiction a useful way of channelling that anger? 

CH: I think it is. As someone recently said, if you’re not angry, you’re not paying attention, and I think there are two different ways you can express that feeling on the page. The first, of course, is by producing obviously angry work. The second is by exploring the relationship between anger and laughter. And whilst I’m furious about a lot of things — austerity, mindless obedience, ‘citrussy’ beer, etc. etc. — there are plenty more that are only fit for ridicule. Which is why I’m drawn to satire, whether that’s Tom Sharp’s Riotous Assembly, or Zoe Pilger’s Eat my Heart Out, or Katherine Mansfield’s The Modern Soul, or Joanna Kavenna or Stewart Home. 

3:AM: You have talked elsewhere about how, in your fiction writing, you tend to vacillate between two extremes. You have an affinity for writing at a distance, with a cool detachment, but you’ve also long been fascinated with interiority and modernist immersion. Both kinds of fiction are apparent in The State of Us. ‘Work’ and ‘Pulling Together’, for instance, are written in the third person with more satirical detachment, whereas ‘On the International Space Station’ and ‘When Helen Levitt Met Vivian Maier’ are written as first person monologues with close attention to character interiority. Can you say something about the process of writing from each of these points of view and whether you find one harder?

CH: I find writing at a distance much harder, because it’s difficult to generate the energy — the intellectual or emotional propulsion — that all prose needs. ‘Energy’, in the context of prose fiction, is often associated with cheap tricks, and a conservative mindset, but even the Tom McCarthys of this world need to create that propulsion, or pages would be left unturned and books unread. Writing interior monologues, or streams of consciousness, is easier. At least it is if you’ve done your research and spent enough time thinking about the character. It’s more fun too, although you have to guard against self-indulgence.

3:AM: Your fiction addresses the political and cultural state of the UK. ‘Take Back Control’, with its character of Nigel who believes he is ‘sticking it’ to the establishment and standing up for people like himself while actually engaged in a futile, juvenile act of rebellion, is clearly an allegory for Brexit. ‘Pulling Together’ explores the growing hostility to people perceived as ‘other’ under the guise of filling out a form, Be a Better Neighbour. ‘The State of Us’ is a speculative story about how a melting pot of people and cultures make up modern, post-war Birmingham. Can you tell us a little about why this subject preoccupies you as a writer? How do you go about balancing the political and narrative aspects of your stories?

CH: I write a lot about Birmingham because I’m from there, and have lived there all my life. I’m ambivalent about the significance of this circumstance to my understanding of the world, though (in this I’d endorse what Damian Lanigan of Weatherglass Books has said about Manchester, his home city: ‘Just like anywhere else? Maybe, but maybe not.’). And although I understand the importance of ‘place’ to fiction, I’m resentful about being reduced to ‘a Birmingham writer’.

I’m preoccupied with rebellion because over the course of the last twenty years, social media has turned us all into rebels (or at least has helped make our rebellious impulses more visible (if only to ourselves). Whether or not that’s the same thing is moot. I don’t think of politics and narrative as being distinct, because I think that all politics has a narrative and all narratives are political. Or, to put it another way, I take the old-fashioned view that everything is political, that every interaction and behaviour — everything we think or don’t think, and do or don’t do — has real-world consequences for other people. 

Although, Jesus. When you put it like that… 

3:AM: Some stories seem to be set in speculative, if recognisable, worlds. ‘Taking Tapas on the Terrace’ takes place in an unnamed but familiar city. The night after a controversial mayor has been elected, two couples have dinner on the roof terrace of one of their apartments. Tensions emerge, especially between the wealthy George, who supports the mayor, and his friend Maddy, who doesn’t. This is a world in which politics isn’t just a matter of difference in opinion. A riot (with gunfire) has started in the city in the aftermath of the controversial mayor’s election. George, whose apartment building is protected by two armed African men, seems to treat the whole shenanigans as a bit of a game and enjoys goading Maddy about the fact that his candidate won. The story seems in part to be a meditation on class and privilege, and how these can blind a person to the real consequences of their political choices for others (and themselves). Is that a fair assessment?

CH: It is. Audrey Lorde famously tried to move progressive discourse away from the idea of a hierarchy of oppression, but I think there’s little doubt that the structural imbalances related to class attract far less remedial attention than, say, those related to gender or race. We seem to have been side-tracked by quibbling over definitions, and what ‘class’ actually means, whereas in practical terms we could do worse than start from the point of ‘economic status’.

3:AM: ‘On the International Space Station’ is about a man alone on the space station who keeps trying to communicate with the home base of Houston. Is there any nod to ‘Houston, Do you Read Me’ by James Tiptree Jr, the 1978 sci-fi short story. Also, this is the longest story in the book and I wonder if you could say something about how easy the first person voice was to hone because I found it so convincing. Part of the magic of writing is being able to experiment with unusual points of view, but to pull off a monologue like this about what may be the end of the world seems an act of radical empathy. 

CH: Thank you! I like the sound of radical empathy! I haven’t read that story though. ‘On the International Space Station’ took years to write and I only persevered because I thought it was an original idea; if I’d known there was something else like it, I probably wouldn’t have bothered.

It might be convincing because I did a ridiculous amount of research into both the International Space Station and Toronto. Then again, it was supposed to be about a woman. And given you’re the second person out of not very many to think it was a man, I’ve got to consider the possibility it wasn’t my most successful act of ventriloquism…

3:AM: I reread ‘On the International Space Station’ to work out why I thought the protagonist was a man. Actually, I think I misread it because the way you have written the character doesn’t seem obviously gendered. Could you say something briefly about the process of writing the character and why you, the author, consider her to be a woman? I found her interesting and convincing regardless, a person who goes through all kinds of thoughts and emotions.

CH: I wanted my astronaut to be a woman because, although I’ve never read a story about an astronaut of any gender, I’m guessing there are more in which the astronaut is male. I also think that as long as it is done with care and respect, it’s important that authors continue to make use of life experiences that differ from their own. Not least because this is an integral element of writing fiction. I didn’t obviously gender the character, though. I just imagined her to be a she as I was writing the story. And, to go back to my research, I made sure I focused on the experiences of women astronauts (YouTube is great in that respect, with everything from guided tours of the ISS, to the spoken testimony of female astronauts from a variety of space programmes…)

3:AM: What are you working on at the moment? Any projects in the pipeline you’d like to tell our readers about? 

CH: I have a second collection of short stories coming out in August. It’s called Encounters with Everyday Madness, and whereas this one is principally outward-looking, Encounters… focuses on interiority, and various depictions of consciousness. 

More Charlie Hill in 3:AM Magazine here and there.

 

Charlie Hill by Dave McGowan

ABOUT THE INTERVIEWEE
Charlie Hill is a writer of long and short form fiction and memoir. His work has been compared by his peers to Georges Perec, Beckett and Kafka. His most recent book, The State of Us, is available from Fly on the Wall Press.

ABOUT THE INTERVIEWER
Katy Wimhurst’s first collection of short stories was Snapshots of the Apocalypse. Her fiction has been published in numerous magazines and anthologies including The Guardian, Writers’ Forum, Cafe Irreal, and ShooterLit. Her first book of visual poems, Fifty-One Trillion Bits, is to be published by Trickhouse Press. She is housebound with the illness M.E.

Share